Lake Toxaway
Lake Toxaway real estate, every home, every condo and every sale, by Mark Zilbert, Broker-in-Charge.
ALERTS FOR LAKE TOXAWAY
E-mail me when
Rentals. Sign in to follow
How often
Find it any time in My Zilbert › Searches & Alerts. Change or stop the emails there.
Zilbert features 62 homes and 1 condo for sale in Lake Toxaway today.
For Sale
39 homes for sale in Lake Toxaway, sorted by price.
| Address ⇅ | Price ⇅ | Listed ⇅ |
|---|---|---|
| 140 Panther Summit DriveHome 5 bed · 7,104 SqFt | $9,995,000$1,407/SqFt | 6/22/266/22 |
| 1957 & 1923 Cold Mountain RoadHome 4 bed · 4,577 SqFt | $9,000,000$1,966/SqFt | 5/8/265/8 |
| 138 Indian TraceHome 4 bed · 5,608 SqFt | $8,995,000$1,604/SqFt · ▼5.3% | 4/3/264/3 |
| 2235 Cold Mountain RoadHome 4 bed · 4,410 SqFt | $6,500,000$1,474/SqFt | 5/18/265/18 |
| 1914 Toxaway DriveHome 3 bed · 4,673 SqFt | $5,995,000$1,283/SqFt | 9/22/269/22 |
| 64 Bee Tree WayHome 4 bed · 5,766 SqFt | $5,995,000$1,040/SqFt · ▼11.2% | 5/1/265/1 |
| 1585 Cold Mountain RoadHome 4 bed · 3,943 SqFt | $4,995,000$1,267/SqFt | 5/21/265/21 |
| 1957 Cold Mountain RoadHome 4 bed · 4,577 SqFt | $4,750,000$1,038/SqFt | 5/8/265/8 |
| 1923 Cold Mountain RoadHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $4,250,000 | 5/8/265/8 |
| 73 Lake Point DriveHome 3 bed · 2,765 SqFt | $4,200,000$1,519/SqFt | 8/18/268/18 |
| 132 Red Bird CircleHome 4 bed · 3,275 SqFt | $3,995,000$1,220/SqFt · ▼4.7% | 11/13/2511/13/25 |
| 100 Meadow Ridge DriveHome 4 bed · 4,691 SqFt | $3,875,000$826/SqFt | 6/25/266/25 |
| 596 W Club BoulevardHome 4 bed · 7,478 SqFt | $3,750,000$501/SqFt | 8/20/268/20 |
| 46 Mills Creek DriveHome 4 bed · 6,402 SqFt | $3,399,000$531/SqFt · ▼1.5% | 4/3/264/3 |
| 96 Moltz CourtHome 3 bed · 4,659 SqFt | $3,350,000$719/SqFt · ▼9.3% | 4/1/264/1 |
| 770 Meadow Ridge DriveHome 5 bed · 5,181 SqFt | $3,280,000$633/SqFt · ▼8.9% | 7/31/257/31/25 |
| 228 Mills Creek TraceHome 4 bed · 4,478 SqFt | $2,975,000$664/SqFt · ▼4.8% | 5/1/255/1/25 |
| D51-52 North Club Boulevard LotHome SiteUnit D51-52 — bed · — SqFt | $2,900,000 · ▼23.7% | 8/31/258/31/25 |
| 1052 Toxaway DriveHome 4 bed · 5,935 SqFt | $2,699,000$455/SqFt | 5/6/265/6 |
| 743 Hawk Mountain RoadHome 4 bed · 3,234 SqFt | $2,556,000$790/SqFt | 8/9/268/9 |
| 601 Hawk Mountain RoadUnder ContractHome 4 bed · 2,723 SqFt | $1,600,000$588/SqFt | 5/4/265/4 |
| 40 Toxaway Landing DriveHome 3 bed · 1,205 SqFt | $1,495,000$1,241/SqFt | 12/26/2512/26/25 |
| 412 Cherokee TraceHome 3 bed · 2,401 SqFt | $1,495,000$623/SqFt · ▼6.6% | 10/14/2510/14/25 |
| 212 SE Shore DriveHome 3 bed · 2,660 SqFt | $1,400,000$526/SqFt · ▼11.9% | 5/21/265/21 |
| 516 Cherokee TraceHome 4 bed · 3,135 SqFt | $1,395,000$445/SqFt | 5/2/265/2 |
| 1580 Fairway DriveHome 3 bed · 2,554 SqFt | $1,195,000$468/SqFt · ▼0.4% | 4/1/264/1 |
| TBD Fairway DriveHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $1,100,000 · ▲22.9% | 6/3/256/3/25 |
| TBD Cardinal Drive LotHome SiteUnit 1A & 1 B — bed · — SqFt | $1,000,000 · ▼33.3% | 9/14/259/14/25 |
| L 9A R Old Mine PointHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $795,000 · ▲14.4% | 12/23/2512/23/25 |
| Lot 114R Toxaway DriveHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $750,000 | 7/1/267/1 |
| 560 Toxaway CourtHome 3 bed · 1,589 SqFt | $650,000$409/SqFt | 5/15/265/15 |
| Lot 42 Spencer Lane LotHome SiteUnit MR42 — bed · — SqFt | $499,000 | 7/5/267/5 |
| River Camp Long Ridge RoadHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $475,000 | 7/1/267/1 |
| 2 Cardinal Drive W LotHome SiteUnit TRP 2 — bed · — SqFt | $475,000 | 6/2/266/2 |
| TBD Long Ridge RoadHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $450,000 | 7/1/267/1 |
| TRP 1 Cardinal Drive WHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $425,000 | 4/1/264/1 |
| PS 3 Panther Summit DriveHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $395,000 | 6/16/246/16/24 |
| M L33 Cardinal DriveHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $350,000 | 8/23/268/23 |
| I-12 Seminole WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $350,000 · ▲27.3% | 11/22/2311/22/23 |
Averages are weighted as total dollars over total square feet. We calculate averages based on closed sales in the MLS for the past 12 months, as of September 29, 2026. Averages are based on properties that are listed or sold for $350,000 and greater. Additional reports at all price points are available here. Price-per-square-foot figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, up or down. Where fewer than 5 closed sales exist in the window, we report the count rather than an average.
| Condos · Avg Selling Price | $796/SqFt · 6 sales |
|---|---|
| Homes · Avg Selling Price | $662/SqFt · 24 sales |
| Asking today, all prices | $70,000 to $9,995,000 |
The page above reports from $350,000; this table has no price floor. Same 12-month window, same exclusions before 1990, same minimum sample of 5.