Lake Toxaway

Lake Toxaway real estate, every home, every condo and every sale, by Mark Zilbert, Broker-in-Charge.

Zilbert features 104 homes and 12 condos for sale in Lake Toxaway today.

Lake Toxaway, North Carolina
1 / 1

Zilbert features 104 homes and 12 condos for sale in Lake Toxaway today.

Ask Mark
Mark Zilbert, Broker-in-Charge
Mark Zilbert
Broker-in-Charge
Zilbert
Your contact for Lake Toxaway
Condos · Avg Selling Price
$617/SqFt
6 Closed Sales · 12 Months
Homes · Avg Selling Price
$573/SqFt
39 Closed Sales · 12 Months
Today’s Prices
$249,900 – $9.5M
12 condos · 104 homes
Sales in Last 12 Months
45
$72,274,354 in closed sales
$1,606,097 was average selling price

For Sale

104 homes for sale in Lake Toxaway, sorted by price.

Address ⇅Subdivision ⇅Price ⇅$/SqFt ⇅Beds/Baths ⇅SqFt ⇅Listed ⇅

Map

The outline is the homes we know in Lake Toxaway, not a surveyed boundary.

Averages are weighted as total dollars over total square feet. We calculate averages based on closed sales in the MLS for the past 12 months, as of November 16, 2026. Averages are based on properties that are listed or sold for $350,000 and greater. Additional reports at all price points are available here. Price-per-square-foot figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, up or down. Where fewer than 5 closed sales exist in the window, we report the count rather than an average.

Mark ZilbertAsk Mark