Horse Shoe
Horse Shoe real estate, every home, every condo and every sale, by Mark Zilbert, Broker-in-Charge.
Zilbert features 56 homes for sale in Horse Shoe today.
ALERTS FOR HORSE SHOE
E-mail me when
Rentals. Sign in to follow
How often
Find it any time in My Zilbert › Searches & Alerts. Change or stop the emails there.


Zilbert features 56 homes for sale in Horse Shoe today.

For Sale
56 homes for sale in Horse Shoe, sorted by price.
| Address ⇅ | Price ⇅ | Listed ⇅ |
|---|---|---|
| 567 Davey Branch RoadHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $4,500,000 | 8/28/268/28 |
| 959 & 957 Dave Whitaker RoadHome 3 bed · 2,954 SqFt | $4,270,000$1,445/SqFt · ▼12.9% | 5/21/265/21 |
| 23 Benton Farms LaneUnder ContractHome 5 bed · 3,246 SqFt | $1,999,999$616/SqFt · ▼20.0% | 5/19/265/19 |
| 361 Mills River WayHome 4 bed · 5,937 SqFt | $1,599,000$269/SqFt · ▼5.7% | 9/13/269/13 |
| 87 Mont Clair TrailUnit 31 3 bed · 4,877 SqFt | $1,595,000$327/SqFt | 8/11/268/11 |
| 37 Mont Clair TrailNewUnit 33 3 bed · 3,735 SqFt | $1,475,000$395/SqFt | 11/11/2611/11 |
| 91 Watershed WayHome 4 bed · 4,138 SqFt | $1,398,000$338/SqFt · ▼3.5% | 7/7/267/7 |
| 285 Ascension ValleyUnit 10 3 bed · 3,603 SqFt | $1,375,000$382/SqFt | 10/28/2610/28 |
| 723 Ascension ValleyUnder ContractUnit 27 3 bed · 3,189 SqFt | $1,375,000$431/SqFt | 9/5/269/5 |
| 165 Horizon View DriveUnder ContractHome 4 bed · 2,594 SqFt | $875,000$337/SqFt | 10/13/2610/13 |
| 181 Byron Forest DriveUnder ContractHome 3 bed · 3,348 SqFt | $875,000$261/SqFt · ▼7.1% | 7/9/267/9 |
| 73 Hudson HollowUnder ContractHome 3 bed · 2,590 SqFt | $800,000$309/SqFt | 9/9/269/9 |
| 78 Byron Forest DriveNewUnit 3 3 bed · 2,192 SqFt | $799,000$365/SqFt | 11/12/2611/12 |
| 80 Hidden Bluff LaneUnder ContractHome 2 bed · 2,917 SqFt | $675,000$231/SqFt | 9/29/269/29 |
| 6 Ravenwood LaneHome 3 bed · 3,166 SqFt | $659,000$208/SqFt · ▼4.5% | 3/13/263/13 |
| 267 Hearthstone WayUnit 10 & 11 COMBINED 3 bed · 1,747 SqFt | $650,000$372/SqFt | 11/6/2611/6 |
| 174 Twisted Tree LaneHome 2 bed · 1,647 SqFt | $629,000$382/SqFt | 10/18/2610/18 |
| 137 Carroll Mountain RoadUnit 4 4 bed · 2,500 SqFt | $599,000$240/SqFt · ▼7.8% | 10/27/2610/27 |
| 366 View DriveHome 2 bed · 2,194 SqFt | $575,000$262/SqFt · ▼1.7% | 10/30/2610/30 |
| 205 Forest Bend DriveUnder ContractHome 3 bed · 2,000 SqFt | $525,000$263/SqFt | 9/28/269/28 |
| 219 Greens View DriveHome 3 bed · 2,843 SqFt | $515,000$181/SqFt | 10/2/2610/2 |
| 5 Amber DriveUnder ContractHome 3 bed · 2,110 SqFt | $484,000$229/SqFt | 11/5/2611/5 |
| 20 Amber DriveHome 4 bed · 2,674 SqFt | $479,900$179/SqFt · ▼7.5% | 7/23/267/23 |
| 40 Meadow DriveUnder ContractHome 3 bed · 1,702 SqFt | $464,900$273/SqFt · ▼2.1% | 8/28/268/28 |
| 4103 Turnpike RoadHome 3 bed · 1,087 SqFt | $383,000$352/SqFt · ▼3.8% | 9/16/269/16 |
| 210 Leigh Anne LaneHome 3 bed · 1,466 SqFt | $299,900$205/SqFt · ▼11.8% | 8/4/268/4 |
| 183 Gobbler CircleHome 3 bed · 1,456 SqFt | $299,000$205/SqFt · ▼3.2% | 10/1/2610/1 |
| 505 Crescent WayHome 3 bed · 1,353 SqFt | $249,900$185/SqFt · ▼16.7% | 7/23/267/23 |
| lot 53R Mills River Way LotHome SiteUnit LOT 53R — bed · — SqFt | $119,900 | 7/10/267/10 |
| Woodhen Way LotHome SiteUnit 138 & 139 — bed · — SqFt | $100,000 · ▼33.3% | 7/13/267/13 |
| 472 Mills River WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $99,500 | 7/8/267/8 |
| Shining Rock Path LotHome SiteUnit 17R — bed · — SqFt | $99,000 | 9/7/269/7 |
| 1647 Mills River WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $98,000 | 2/19/262/19 |
| Lot 11 Shining Rock PathHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $92,000 | 7/14/267/14 |
| 1018 Mills River WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $91,000 | 7/8/247/8/24 |
| 838 Mills River WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $89,900 | 9/5/269/5 |
| Caddis Lane LotHome SiteUnit 92 — bed · — SqFt | $82,500 | 7/14/267/14 |
| Lot 12 Shining Rock PathHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $80,000 | 7/14/267/14 |
| Mills River Way LotHome SiteUnit 108 — bed · — SqFt | $79,900 | 7/14/267/14 |
| 80 Buckhead Trail LotHome SiteUnit 27 — bed · — SqFt | $77,500 | 7/13/267/13 |
| Amber Drive S LotUnder ContractHome SiteNewUnit 30 — bed · — SqFt | $74,900 | 11/10/2611/10 |
| Mayfly Lane LotHome SiteUnit 106 — bed · — SqFt | $73,500 | 7/13/267/13 |
| 567 Shining Rock PathHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $69,500 | 7/8/247/8/24 |
| N Running Deer Trail LotHome SiteUnit 85R — bed · — SqFt | $68,500 | 9/2/269/2 |
| 230 Shining Rock Path LotHome SiteUnit 64 — bed · — SqFt | $67,500 | 9/15/269/15 |
| Amber Drive S LotUnder ContractHome SiteNewUnit 35 — bed · — SqFt | $67,000 | 11/10/2611/10 |
| 80 Running Deer Trail S LotHome SiteUnit 80 — bed · — SqFt | $65,500 | 4/19/264/19 |
| 140 Woodhen Way LotHome SiteUnit 140 — bed · — SqFt | $60,000 | 4/19/264/19 |
| 116 May Fly Lane LotHome SiteUnit 116 — bed · — SqFt | $52,000 | 4/19/264/19 |
| 1094 Mills River WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $49,000 · ▼10.9% | 4/9/264/9 |
| 1114 Mills River WayHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $48,000 | 11/21/2511/21/25 |
| Shining Rock Path LotHome SiteUnit 69 — bed · — SqFt | $45,000 | 6/19/266/19 |
| 999 Windy Cove DriveHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $39,900 · ▼20.0% | 2/27/262/27 |
| Caddis Lane LotHome SiteUnit 91 — bed · — SqFt | $30,000 | 7/17/267/17 |
| Mills River Way LotHome SiteUnit LOT 107 — bed · — SqFt | $25,000 | 7/17/267/17 |
| Shining Rock PathHome SiteHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $22,500 | 11/18/2511/18/25 |
Map
The outline is the homes we know in Horse Shoe, not a surveyed boundary.
Averages are weighted as total dollars over total square feet. We calculate averages based on closed sales in the MLS for the past 12 months, as of November 13, 2026. Averages are based on properties that are listed or sold for $350,000 and greater. Additional reports at all price points are available here. Price-per-square-foot figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, up or down. Where fewer than 5 closed sales exist in the window, we report the count rather than an average.
| Homes · Avg Selling Price | $319/SqFt · 32 sales |
|---|---|
| Asking today, all prices | $22,500 to $4,500,000 |
The page above reports from $350,000; this table has no price floor. Same 12-month window, same exclusions before 1990, same minimum sample of 5.

