Horse Shoe

Zilbert features 34 homes for sale in Horse Shoe today.

Homes · Avg Selling Price

$420/SqFt

6 Closed Sales · 12 Months

Today’s Prices

$1,275k – $1,775k

34 homes

Sales in Last 12 Months

$8,540,000 in closed sales

$1,423,333 was average selling price

For Sale

All Homes · 163

9 homes & condos for sale in Horse Shoe, sorted by price.

Address ⇅	Subdivision ⇅	Price ⇅		$/SqFt ⇅	Beds/Baths ⇅	SqFt ⇅	Acres ⇅	Listed ⇅
163 Stonefly DriveHome 4 bed · 3,857 SqFt	Homestead at Mills River	$1,775,000$460/SqFt		$460	4/3½	3,857	1.31	6/26/266/26
361 Mills River WayHome 4 bed · 5,937 SqFt	Homestead at Mills River	$1,695,000$285/SqFt		$285	4/4½	5,937	2.40	9/13/269/13
671 Mills River WayHome 4 bed · 4,568 SqFt	Homestead at Mills River	$1,599,900$350/SqFt · ▼15.3%	▼15.3%	$350	4/4½	4,568	1.33	5/3/265/3
87 Mont Clair TrailUnit 31 3 bed · 4,499 SqFt	Horse Shoe Cove	$1,595,000$355/SqFt		$355	3/3½	4,499	0.80	8/11/268/11
91 Watershed WayHome 4 bed · 4,138 SqFt	Homestead at Mills River	$1,449,000$350/SqFt		$350	4/4½	4,138	1.78	7/7/267/7
723 Ascension ValleyUnit 27 3 bed · 3,189 SqFt	Horse Shoe Cove	$1,375,000$431/SqFt		$431	3/3½	3,189	1.15	9/5/269/5
67 Mont Clair TrailHome 3 bed · 3,138 SqFt	Horse Shoe Cove	$1,345,000$429/SqFt · ▲17.5%	▲17.5%	$429	3/3½	3,138	1.05	10/22/2510/22/25
83 Mont Clair TrailUnder ContractUnit 32 3 bed · 3,138 SqFt	Horse Shoe Cove	$1,344,500$428/SqFt		$428	3/3½	3,138	1.31	10/29/2510/29/25
422 Ascension ValleyHome 3 bed · 2,852 SqFt	Horse Shoe Cove	$1,275,000$447/SqFt		$447	3/2½	2,852	2.70	7/31/267/31

Averages are weighted as total dollars over total square feet. We calculate averages based on closed sales in the MLS for the past 12 months, as of September 25, 2026. Averages are based on properties that are listed or sold for $350,000 and greater. Additional reports at all price points are available here. Price-per-square-foot figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, up or down. Where fewer than 5 closed sales exist in the window, we report the count rather than an average.

All price points · Horse Shoe · 12 months, as of September 25, 2026

Homes · Avg Selling Price	$420/SqFt · 6 sales
Asking today, all prices	$22,500 to $1,775,000

The page above reports from $350,000; this table has no price floor. Same 12-month window, same exclusions before 1990, same minimum sample of 5.