Old Cutler Bay
Platted in sections at the southern edge of Coral Gables
ALERTS FOR OLD CUTLER BAY
E-mail me when
Rentals. Sign in to follow
How often
Find it any time in My Zilbert › Searches & Alerts. Change or stop the emails there.
About Old Cutler Bay
Old Cutler Bay sits at the southern edge of Coral Gables, between Gables Estates and the Matheson preserve, and was platted in phases: Section Four at Plat Book 82, page 34, and Section Four-A at Plat Book 84, page 6. The earliest houses on those sections date from 1968 and 1969, which places the community's build-out a decade after the first Davis subdivisions to its north. The canal system reaches Biscayne Bay directly and the lots carry private dockage. It is guard-gated and governed by its own homeowners corporation.
Zilbert features 2 single family homes for sale in Old Cutler Bay today.
For Sale
2 single-family homes for sale in Old Cutler Bay.
| Address ⇅ | Price ⇅ | Listed ⇅ |
|---|---|---|
| 9340 Balada StreetHome SiteNewHome Site — bed · — SqFt | $16,500,000 | 9/15/269/15 |
| 435 Marquesa DriveHome 6 bed · 4,085 SqFt | $12,795,000$3,132/SqFt | 6/12/266/12 |
Pending Sales
Under contract, awaiting closing. Once the property has closed, the sold price will be available.
No homes under contract in Old Cutler Bay at the moment.
Recently Sold Homes
Sorted by date.
| Address ⇅ | Sold Price ⇅ | % of Ask ⇅ | Closed ⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9360 Balada StreetHome 8 bed · 6,771 SqFt | $20,500,000list $22,900,000 | 90% | 6/30/266/30 |
| 9370 Balada StHome 5 bed · 3,997 SqFt | $10,250,000list $10,900,000 | 94% | 5/13/265/13 |
| 610 Reinante AveHome 4 bed · 3,595 SqFt | $5,700,000list $5,700,000 | 100% | 4/30/264/30 |
| 625 Reinante AveHome 6 bed · 8,016 SqFt | $47,000,000list $47,000,000 | 100% | 4/23/264/23 |
| 641 Reinante AveHome 5 bed · 3,360 SqFt | $15,600,000list $15,600,000 | 100% | 4/17/264/17 |
| 180 Solano PradoHome 6 bed · 6,753 SqFt | $13,000,000list $14,250,000 | 91% | 3/30/263/30 |
| 9320 Balada StHome 7 bed · 7,623 SqFt | $17,950,000list $18,950,000 | 95% | 3/19/263/19 |
| 9330 Gallardo StreetHome 6 bed · 8,984 SqFt | $31,000,000list $36,000,000 | 86% | 10/10/2510/10/25 |
Map
Nearby
Averages are weighted as total dollars over total square feet. We calculate averages based on closed sales in the MLS for the past 12 months, as of June 30, 2026. Averages are based on properties that are listed or sold for $350,000 and greater. Additional reports at all price points are available here. Price-per-square-foot figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, up or down. Where fewer than 5 closed sales exist in the window, we report the count rather than an average.
| Homes · Avg Selling Price | $3,080/SqFt · 9 sales |
|---|---|
| Asking today, all prices | $12,000 to $16,500,000 |
The page above reports from $350,000; this table has no price floor. Same 12-month window, same exclusions before 1990, same minimum sample of 5.