‹›159 W Mountain Street
159 W Mountain Street, Rutherfordton, NC 28139
1 / 28

159 W Mountain Street 159 W Mountain Street, Rutherfordton, NC 28139 For Sale

$439,900
159 W Mountain Street · Cummings Cove · Rutherfordton
159 W Mountain Street For Sale
$439,900
Cummings Cove · Rutherfordton, NC 28139
MLS 4425745
159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 1 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 2 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 3 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 4 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 5 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 6 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 7 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 8 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 9 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 10 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 11 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 12 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 13 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 14 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 15 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 16 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 17 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 18 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 19 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 20 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 21 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 22 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 23 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 24 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 25 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 26 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 27 of 28159 W Mountain Street, 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139, photo 28 of 28
$439,900Asking Price
$225Per SqFt
3/1½Beds/BathsBd/Ba
1,959SqFt · 182.0 m²
MLS 4425745 · 13 days on Zilbert · Listed Sep 17, 2026 · 159 W Mountain Street, Cummings Cove, Rutherfordton NC 28139

Property Details

Asking Price$439,900
Price per SqFt$225
Property TaxesNot provided
Interior Space1,959 SqFt
Beds/Baths3/1½
Year Built1963
Acreage2.10 acres
WaterPublic
SewerPublic Sewer
RoadGravel, Paved
CountyRutherford
MLS #4425745

Estimated Costs

An estimate of condo or HOA fees and property taxes

From the listing

This beautiful one-level brick home sits gracefully within the Rutherfordton city limits, offering the rare combination of modern updates and preserved original character. From the moment you arrive, the classic brick exterior and inviting setting hint at the warmth and charm found throughout the interior. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully refreshed while maintaining the personality that makes older homes so special. The layout feels comfortable and functional, and the craftsmanship of the original construction shines through in subtle details. A standout feature is the expansive heated and cooled attic—an impressive space that already feels like a natural extension of the home. With its size and accessibility, it appears to offer excellent potential for future conversion into additional living area, studio, office, or recreation space. This property also includes a valuable bonus: an extra lot offering endless possibilities. Whether you envision selling it, building another home, adding a workshop, creating outdoor amenities, or exploring any use permitted by zoning, the flexibility adds tremendous appeal and long-term potential. Over the past two years, the home has undergone a series of meaningful updates, including new appliances, flooring, windows and doors, HVAC system, tankless water heater, updated plumbing and wiring, new light fixtures, fresh interior paint, gutters, countertops, and bathroom fixtures. These improvements provide peace of mind while enhancing comfort, efficiency, and everyday livability. A charming brick home with modern upgrades, expansion potential, and an additional lot in such a convenient in-town location is a rare find. This property offers both immediate enjoyment and future opportunity for the next owner.

Listed by Odean Keever & Associates, Inc.

Sales History for This Home · 159 W Mountain Street, Rutherfordton, NC 28139

Sales history is unavailable for this property

Mark Zilbert, Broker-in-Charge
Mark Zilbert
Broker-in-Charge · Zilbert · I track every sale in this neighborhood. Ask me about this home or the neighborhood.
+1 (828) 358-4292

Listed by Odean Keever & Associates, Inc.. Mark Zilbert of Zilbert is a cooperating (transaction) broker and helps buyers find properties in Rutherfordton and throughout Western North Carolina.

Location

Directions

The curated data and calculated data for this property and its surrounding condo units and homes is based solely on data we have extracted from the MLS. There may be unpublished, private, quit claim and other property offerings and transfers that do not appear here, which may affect how a buyer or seller perceives property values. Always conduct proper due diligence when considering buying or selling property.

Ask Mark