57 Cayuga Road
57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes, FL 33308
1 / 79
57 Cayuga Road 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes, FL 33308 For Sale
$4,950,000
57 Cayuga Road · Sea Ranch Lakes · Sea Ranch Lakes
57 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 1 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 2 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 3 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 4 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 5 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 6 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 7 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 8 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 9 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 10 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 11 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 12 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 13 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 14 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 15 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 16 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 17 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 18 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 19 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 20 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 21 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 22 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 23 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 24 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 25 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 26 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 27 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 28 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 29 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 30 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 31 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 32 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 33 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 34 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 35 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 36 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 37 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 38 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 39 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 40 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 41 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 42 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 43 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 44 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 45 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 46 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 47 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 48 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 49 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 50 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 51 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 52 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 53 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 54 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 55 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 56 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 57 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 58 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 59 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 60 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 61 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 62 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 63 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 64 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 65 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 66 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 67 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 68 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 69 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 70 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 71 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 72 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 73 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 74 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 75 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 76 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 77 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 78 of 7957 Cayuga Road, 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308, photo 79 of 79
$4,950,000Asking Price
$1,520Per SqFt
3/3½Beds/BathsBd/Ba
3,256SqFt · 302.5 m²
MLS B26021018 · 63 days on Zilbert · Listed Jul 16, 2026 · 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes FL 33308Current layoutPhotos first

Property Details

Asking Price$4,950,000
Price per SqFt$1,520
Maintenance fee$1,200 Quarterly
Property Taxes$12,821 2025
Interior Space3,256 SqFt
Beds/Baths3/3½
Year Built1961
Garage2 spaces
PoolYes
Lot Size0.37 acres
MLS #B26021018

Estimated Costs

An estimate of condo or HOA fees and property taxes

Monthly carry, before financing
$400maintenance · $1,200 per quarter
$1,068taxes · $12,821/yr ÷ 12
$1,468 / monthassociation + taxes, before mortgage and insurance

Fees and taxes based on MLS provided figures, and may not be accurate

From the listing

Bermuda inspired charm meets true coastal exclusivity in the gated Village of Sea Ranch Lakes—one of Florida's most private, police protected enclaves with its own oceanfront Beach Club. Cherished by the same family for decades, this elegant home offers grand flowing living spaces, forever views of Lake Cayuga, Italian marble, warm wood floors, a gourmet kitchen with Butler's Pantry, split bedrooms, full house generator, over-sized pool w/sun shelf and A/C garage. A rare opportunity to shape a legacy property in a community where 24/7 private police create a level of safety so complete that children can roam freely, with a members only Beach Club, playground, and private beach access just moments from fine dining and shopping.

Listed by Coldwell Banker Realty

Sales History for This Home · 57 Cayuga Road, Sea Ranch Lakes, FL 33308

Sales history is unavailable for this property

Mark Zilbert
Mark Zilbert
Licensed Real Estate Broker · I track every sale in this neighborhood. Ask me about this home or the neighborhood.
+1 (786) 280-0201

Listed by Coldwell Banker Realty. Mark Zilbert of ONE Sotheby's International Realty is a cooperating (transaction) broker and helps buyers find properties in Sea Ranch Lakes and throughout South Florida.

Location

Directions

The curated data and calculated data for this property and its surrounding condo units and homes is based solely on data we have extracted from the MLS. There may be unpublished, private, quit claim and other property offerings and transfers that do not appear here, which may affect how a buyer or seller perceives property values. Always conduct proper due diligence when considering buying or selling property.