Fisher Island Bayside Village
2011 to 2543 Fisher Island Drive, Fisher Island, FL 33109
ALERTS FOR FISHER ISLAND BAYSIDE VILLAGE
E-mail me when
Rentals. Sign in to follow
How often
Find it any time in My Zilbert › Searches & Alerts. Change or stop the emails there.
Mark Zilbert is a Miami Beach real estate agent who follows every listing and sale at Fisher Island Bayside Village. Buyers and sellers can call or text Mark at (786) 280-0201.
Building Facts
| Developer | William and Rosamund Vanderbilt |
|---|---|
| Year Built | 1920 |
| Units | 20 |
| Unit sizes | 1,847 – 6,438 SqFt |
About Fisher Island Bayside Village
Originally built in the 1920's by William and Rosamund Vanderbilt as their splendid winter estate, Fisher Island has enjoyed a long, storied history of entertaining the luminaries of its time. Today, 75 years later, it has been restored to its former grandeur. And in the process it has become a world-class private island residential community. Much has been written about Fisher Island, but perhaps nothing more telling than this tribute from Vogue magazine: Fisher Island is centered on the former mansion of William K. Vanderbilt, a 1920's confection used for wintering by the great grandson of the Commodore. There is no mistaking this island for any other land form. From the lovely Vanderbilt Mansion's main Club, its charming ocean side private Beach Club and other intimate restaurants, its superb Mediterranean-inspired Tennis Center, its lovely circa 1925 cottages and guest suite houses, its elaborate deep-sea water marinas, stunning championship golf course and spectacular Spa Internazionale, its distinguished residents . . . truly there is no other land quite like Fisher Island. The classic, mediterranean-style, private residential community of Fisher Island is nestled in a tropical-lush island club resort. Here, residents discover the privacy and security of an island where cultures from 40 nations blend against the backdrop of a cobalt-blue sky and Atlantic Ocean. Placing its residents and guests within all the charms of South Florida, this special destination is only a few minutes away from Miami and Miami Beaches' finest theaters, museums, shopping and nightlife. From it's luxurious spa and health club, pristine beaches and swimming pools, to its tennis, golf, restaurants and lounges, this private community is easy to reach by boat, seaplane, helicopter or car ferry.
By Mark Zilbert, Global Real Estate Advisor · updated September 2026
Asking prices by bedrooms: 2 beds from $3.8M · 3 beds $4.2M to $5.5M
For Sale
11 units · avg asking $1,984/SqFt
| Unit ⇅ | Price ⇅ | Listed ⇅ |
|---|---|---|
| 21222 bed · 1,847 SqFt | $3,750,000$2,030/SqFt | 6/3/266/3 |
| 21333 bed · 1,847 SqFt | $3,789,000$2,051/SqFt · ▲35.9% | 7/18/267/18 |
| 52052 bed · 1,912 SqFt | $3,790,000$1,982/SqFt | 5/21/265/21 |
| 32013 bed · 2,744 SqFt | $4,200,000$1,531/SqFt · ▼15.2% | 5/26/265/26 |
| 20353 bed · 1,912 SqFt | $4,400,000$2,301/SqFt | 9/15/269/15 |
| 21343 bed · 2,744 SqFt | $4,500,000$1,640/SqFt | 8/19/268/19 |
| 21243 bed · 2,744 SqFt | $4,850,000$1,767/SqFt | 7/8/267/8 |
| 33063 bed · 2,744 SqFt | $5,200,000$1,895/SqFt · ▼7.1% | 11/3/2511/3/25 |
| 54033 bed · 3,227 SqFt | $5,250,000$1,627/SqFt · ▼11.0% | 2/5/262/5 |
| 51023 bed · 2,234 SqFt | $5,500,000$2,462/SqFt | 9/28/269/28 |
| 62013 bed · 2,744 SqFt | $7,750,000$2,824/SqFt · ▼16.2% | 12/31/2512/31/25 |
Pending Sales
Under contract, awaiting closing. The freshest signal of where prices are settling. In the MLS: For sale is Active or Active with Contract; these are Pending. The price shown is the asking price. The closed price appears in Sold when it records.
No residences under contract at the moment.
Sold · Last 12 Months
7 closed sales · avg $1,678/SqFt · avg 90% of last asking price
| Unit ⇅ | Sold Price ⇅ | % of Ask ⇅ | Closed ⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 53023 bed · 2,234 SqFt | $3,726,000list $3,900,000 | 96% | 10/2/2610/2 |
| 34052 bed · 1,912 SqFt | $3,800,000list $4,150,000 | 92% | 7/22/267/22 |
| 32052 bed · 1,912 SqFt | $3,603,500list $3,980,000 | 91% | 6/30/266/30 |
| 20422 bed · 1,912 SqFt | $3,216,000list $3,950,000 | 81% | 6/30/266/30 |
| 53073 bed · 3,192 SqFt | $4,700,000list $5,100,000 | 92% | 3/25/263/25 |
| 31034 bed · 3,192 SqFt | $5,350,000list $5,800,000 | 92% | 1/5/261/5 |
| 20213 bed · 2,744 SqFt | $4,300,000list $4,800,000 | 90% | 11/5/2511/5/25 |
% of ask compares the closed price to the final list price. The building's full sold history, 91 sales, lives on the archive view.
Let me know when a unit lists at Fisher Island Bayside Village
We will e-mail you each time there is something new.
Ask Mark About This Condo
Fisher Island Bayside Village, 2011 to 2543 Fisher Island Drive, Fisher Island
Mark sent you this link
Having issues or do you need technical help? Use this form instead: CLICK HERE